Scenario 43

[Hex]

It would partly depend on how many I could comfortably take in.

Then for me it comes down to who could you trust.

Men might not take kindly to having to take orders from someone else and as the saying goes ''behind every great man, is a great woman'' sadly this applies in the opposite to. I've seen fights start because a woman pushed her bloke into it (Macbeth syndrome lol).
Now kids are an awkward area, no-one likes to see children suffer especially their parents. This could lead to desperate acts resulting in casualties to both sides. But that could also work to your advantage having children dependent on their actions might make the parents work harder and the children could learn.

The doctor would sharp get over any dietary problem if he was gonna starve. However depending on the type of doctor he is his skills might be pretty much redundant in a post SHTF world (doctors sent like they used to be).

Now the stockman as has been said, he could always play doctor if need be plus his skills combined with the herbalist could make a good working pair. Even by himself he would be hard to turn away.

As for the herbalist and her husband, he could learn in time and her skills could be very valuable (as already explained).