Weight Limit

[Scythe13]

I get where you're coming from CH, but there's much more to choosing a pack than just looking at the SaR purposes.

Let's look at this hypothetical situation. I'm sure TL won't mind me using him for this exercise. Please note, this is not necessarily accurate information about TL.

1. TL is a family man. Let's say he has the average of 2 children...ages 3 and 5.
2. TL is a healthy man and is used to yomping.
3. TL plans to bug out for 7 days.
4. TL has had to prep alone because his wife doesn't like him prepping.
5. TL's wife has a slight lower back problem.

Right, let's have a look at this.

Firstly, with Mrs TL's back issue, she can't carry much. Maybe a small bag with some child essentials. Okay, there's that sorted, and her out of the 'able bodied assistance' category.
Secondly, kids. Rumour has it that they don't come equipped with panniers or any other kind of massed equipment holding functions. There's them out of the 'able bodied assistance' category too. Useless little critters (I joke).
Thirdly...oh wait, whose going to carry the tent, sleeping equipment, week's worth of food, water, clothing, etc? Well volunteered TL!!! Now, get that tent...because a Basha for a small child is not always a wise idea...3 sleeping bags (kids can share because they're small), cook set, and all the rest and get it all into a 25litre bag?
WHAT?!?!? TL, can't you fit it all in there? You silly goose! How about using a 45litre?
I don't care if it's winter mate, and you have to get all three of your 4 season sleepers into the bag. Why not fit it to the outside of the bag anyway?
Are you serious TL?!?!? What do you mean not enough space on the outside of the bag?!?! Are you even trying mate?
Okay, how about an 85-90 litre bag? Is that any better Mr I Have To Carry Everything?
TL, why are you smiling? Oh that's why. Because it fits.

Great work TL. Bet you're glad you have that massive bag now?


I do get where you're coming from CH, but there are many more considerations to look into.

And everyone knows all TiimeLords have a tardis. He should have just used that, the silly chickenhead.

Different bags for different people. Even more confusingly, different bags for the same person, but for different situations.

It's like I've said before about using a BOB as a GHB. We were in Dartmoor and I asked the guys there. I think it was pretty unanimous, you really can't travel far with a big BOB quickly. For a GHB you want something small and mobile. The only people I think that could travel with a pretty big BOB for any distance is MikeA and Arnie (from the forum, whom I've not seen for a while), and I only say that because MikeA does it for a job, and Arnie is 6'4" and each step he takes is like 15 meters long haha.