Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Minimum Growing Space
4 May 2014, 21:46,
#13
RE: Minimum Growing Space
(28 April 2014, 23:28)Mortblanc Wrote: The estimates given are absurdly small. They also are dependent in every crop being successful at full production. They are also not including maize in their calculations and are heavy on the wheat, which is much less versatile and robust in a survival setting. These people are mathematicians and not cooks or farmers.

5 eggs per week?

3 servings of pork?

Zero beef ration???

Zero chicken meat ration??

I love that comment "If you wish to add dairy". Butter and cheese are staples of rural calorie intake.

2300 VEGITARIAN calories with low fat and questionable protein intake per day on a working farm?????

2300 calories is the recommendation for sedentary office workers, not people doing intense farm labor.

Following those guidelines one would need to work very hard in order to starve decently


^^^that.

In the UK you will struggle to death to grow 2300 calories for you to consume by consuming 2300 calories. You would be putting more work in than you would be getting out.

Subsistence living and subsistence farming I would reckon on it starting out putting another 1500 calories a day on your needs, minimum in the UK.

You could grow maize to feed animals, but it is by no means a decent feed as the major part of the feed - you would end up with very poor animals on it. The graphic does not give the yield, but we will not get a USA return in the UK. It is also a very hungry crop. You would be better off buying in animal feed, so you would need some money.

You have to factor in that in a UK climate, you are going to need to manage woodland for firewood.

If you are getting top class produce and lots of it from your land, you will need years of experience and to really know you land and treat it right and have the inputs at hand to use.

For a family of four, good land, good aspect, right livestock for the land, things set up in such a way they were efficient and you do not want to rely on a lot of outside inputs other than to pay for the things they cannot reasonably supply themselves, two acres of good or improved land - you can improve it through you own work and the work of livestock, two acres of pastures, four acres of hay and six acres of mixed woodland, nine or more being better.


(29 April 2014, 22:34)Devonian Wrote: Also its not about coping with limited space, its about how much space do you "realistically" need to feed yourself/your family?

12 acres I would say with some basic, but good living.
Reply


Messages In This Thread
Minimum Growing Space - by Devonian - 28 April 2014, 22:40
RE: Minimum Growing Space - by MaryN - 28 April 2014, 22:47
RE: Minimum Growing Space - by Scythe13 - 28 April 2014, 23:04
RE: Minimum Growing Space - by Devonian - 28 April 2014, 23:06
RE: Minimum Growing Space - by Scythe13 - 28 April 2014, 23:23
RE: Minimum Growing Space - by Mortblanc - 28 April 2014, 23:28
RE: Minimum Growing Space - by River Song - 29 April 2014, 06:46
RE: Minimum Growing Space - by SecretPrepper - 29 April 2014, 11:48
RE: Minimum Growing Space - by MaryN - 29 April 2014, 20:21
RE: Minimum Growing Space - by Devonian - 29 April 2014, 20:46
RE: Minimum Growing Space - by Steve - 29 April 2014, 21:56
RE: Minimum Growing Space - by Devonian - 29 April 2014, 22:34
RE: Minimum Growing Space - by BDG - 4 May 2014, 21:46
RE: Minimum Growing Space - by MaryN - 4 May 2014, 22:06
RE: Minimum Growing Space - by Mortblanc - 4 May 2014, 23:41

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 13 Guest(s)